Home https://server7.kproxy.com/servlet/redirect.srv/sruj/smyrwpoii/p2/ US https://server7.kproxy.com/servlet/redirect.srv/sruj/smyrwpoii/p2/ A federal judge has blocked a law on abortion counseling in Tennessee

A federal judge has blocked a law on abortion counseling in Tennessee



A July law requires Tennessee abortion providers to tell abortion seekers that abortion with drugs – a non-surgical procedure effective up to about 10 weeks of pregnancy that usually involves taking two drugs at intervals of several days – can be canceled. The law also requires that information about the procedure be made available on the State Department of Health’s website and that providers inform patients about it.

Such requirements have been widely criticized by medical teams, and researchers in California have stopped a 2019 trial designed to examine “reversal abortion” treatment early for safety reasons.
The American Medical Association ̵
1; the main industry group of doctors that is suing North Dakota for a similar law in 2019 – called such allegations of reversing a medical abortion “completely unsupported by the best and most reliable scientific evidence.” The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists said that claims of “abortion abortion” were not supported by science, “criticizing” legislative mandates forcing doctors to refer women to this unproven course of treatment. ”
This victory for abortion rights advocates comes as both sides in the abortion rights debate prepare for a Supreme Court battle for nominated Judge Amy Connie Barrett to fill the vacancy left by the late Judge Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Confirming Barrett, who has expressed views against abortion rights and would secure a 6-3 conservative majority in court, could have profound implications for the future of abortion rights.
Tennessee law will require such warnings from the doctor at least 48 hours before the abortion, again in writing after taking the first pill and written on “visibly” displayed signs in private offices, outpatient surgery centers, facilities and clinics that have provided more than 50 abortions in the previous calendar year. Violation of the bylaws could result in abortion providers with up to six years in prison and health centers with a $ 10,000 fine.

Tennessee abortion providers, joined by Planned Parenthood, the American Civil Liberties Union and its Tennessee affiliate, and the Center for Reproductive Rights, challenged the law in August by filing a lawsuit against Tennessee Republican Attorney General Herbert Slater and other Tennessee officials for to force them to publish “untrue, misleading and inappropriate information. “

Judge William Campbell wrote on Tuesday that he “could not fully assess the competing expert opinions on whether the mandate message was ‘true and not misleading’ in the absence of expert testimony”, but found that “another aspect of the mandate was” misleading “. ”

He noted that since abortion providers have to start reporting that abortion reversal information is available on the Ministry of Health’s website from October 1, the deadline for the State Department of Health to publish the information is January 1, “such information and assistance may not be available “such that” a patient wishing to gain access to such information would not be able to do so “.

Campbell noted that “the plaintiffs have demonstrated a strong or significant likelihood of success in the substance of their claims that (the set of requirements) violates the First Amendment by requiring abortion providers to send a mandatory message that is misleading.” The block of the law will last until October 13, the date for which Campbell has scheduled a hearing in the case.

Slatery’s office said in a statement to CNN on Wednesday that Campbell’s order “simply maintains the status quo until the district court can hold a preliminary hearing,” adding that “we look forward to presenting evidence during the constitutional hearing.” of the law. “

Ashley Cofield, chief executive of Planned Parenthood of Tennessee and Northern Mississippi, hailed the “victory in blocking another failed policy” while slapping “how anti-abortion politicians are running the Trump administration’s program against our rights and freedoms – without public contribution and against the will of the people. “

Tennessee is not alone as a result of such a law of late. Arkansas, Kentucky, Nebraska, North Dakota and Oklahoma all codified measures in 2019 require abortion providers to tell patients that abortion with drugs can be canceled. Last year, a federal judge blocked the North Dakota law.
And reversing medical abortion is not the only aspect of the procedure that the state seeks to regulate. The law, which requires a warning to reverse an abortion, also prohibits abortions after a fetal heartbeat is detected, which can occur as early as six weeks of pregnancy and before many people find out they are pregnant. Campbell also temporarily blocked the provision in July.

CNN’s Veronica Stracalursi contributed to this report.




Source link