Home https://server7.kproxy.com/servlet/redirect.srv/sruj/smyrwpoii/p2/ Sport https://server7.kproxy.com/servlet/redirect.srv/sruj/smyrwpoii/p2/ College Football Playoff Reactions For The playoffs: Georgia Overrated, Oklahoma Underrated

College Football Playoff Reactions For The playoffs: Georgia Overrated, Oklahoma Underrated

As expected after a weekend involving two of the top four teams, this week there was a shaking of the top of the football playoff standings. LSU climbed from No. 2 to No. 1 after beating Alabama, which dropped to No. 5. Ohio State and Clemson finished at No. 2 and No. 3, respectively.

Then there was what was probably the biggest surprise: Georgia was moving up two points from No. 6 to No. 4, and that's where we start this week with our reactions to the second edition of the CFP rankings.

No. 4 Georgia – Overrated

SEC: It just means more … unless it's a loss to South Carolina. Then it means nothing. Seriously, let's get through the teams in the top 1

0 this week according to the CFP Selection Committee. Of these 10 teams, four have no loss. The other six teams have six losses to each other. Here's a list of the teams that beat those six: No. 1 LSU, No. 8 Minnesota, No. 12 Auburn, No. 24 Kansas State, USC … South Carolina.

Somehow, the team with the worst of those losses would be in the College College playoffs if the season ended right now. Of course, the commission will cite Georgia's wins over No. 11 Florida and No. 16 Notre Dame as reasons to rank her so high, and I don't reject those wins. Only a few teams in the country have two better victories than those in their resume.

But it is also difficult to find teams with losses to South Carolina in their resumption because South Carolina has won only four games this season. Those four wins came against Charleston South, Kentucky, Vanderbilt and, of course, Georgia. The same team that beat Georgia just lost at home to Appalachian No. 25 on Saturday. A week after the Appalachian state lost at home to Georgia South.

Now, comparing Georgia's summary to No. 5 in Alabama, as I said above, Georgia has better wins. What Alabama lacks, however, is a loss to South Carolina. His lone loss had just reached LSU's No. 5 spot with a quarterback who wasn't completely healthy. If there is any good news, Georgia still has many chances to prove its worth. He gets No. 12 Auburn this weekend and if he wins the SEC East, he will face LSU or maybe Alabama in the SEC Championship Game. So if he wins, he'll deserve to be in the top four. However, this is not happening right now.

No. 10 Oklahoma – Underrated

Why does the committee hate Oklahoma so much? I can understand that the Sunnis ranked behind Penn State and Minnesota. Penn State has better wins, and Minnesota's win over Penn State is better than Oklahoma's best win. Also, losing Oklahoma to No. 24 in Kansas is "worse" than losing Penn. But why is Utah and Oregon ahead of the Sooness?

Oklahoma's best win is a 34-27 win over No. 19 Texas on a neutral field. Utah's best win is either a 33-28 victory at 6-4 Washington, or a 21-3 victory over 5-4 Arizona State. Oregon's best win is either a 35-31 win over that same Washington team or a 56-24 win at 6-4 USC. So, judging by the committee's ranking, Oklahoma has the best profit.

Now let's compare their losses. Oklahoma lost 48-41 on the way to No. 24 Kansas. Oregon lost to No. 12 Ore 27-21 on neutral ground. Utah lost to broken USC, which Oregon won by 32 points. So Oklahoma has the best win of the three, and Oregon has the best loss. So, well, if you want to rank Oregon in front of Oklahoma, there's a strong argument for that. But what is the Utah argument for Oklahoma? The Sunnis have the best win between the two, while Utah has the worst loss.

No. 14 Wisconsin – Overrated

The Committee has overestimated Wisconsin, but it does because it has no choice. No one who has watched Wisconsin in his last three games would have believed it to be the 14th best team in the country, but the commission is a puzzle. He can't rank Wisconsin behind a Michigan team that wins 35-14, nor can he rank the Badgers behind a Notre Dame team that Michigan wins. And we all know he couldn't bring a group of five losses with five losses like Cincinnati and Memphis to those three. That would be anarchy! So I understand why Wisconsin is number 14 and I respect the committee's position, but that doesn't mean it's not overrated.

No. 20 Iowa – Overrated

Iowa has an 18-17 road win over Iowa. It's his best win and a good win, but even so, Iowa State is currently a 5-4 team. A 5-4 team that carries a lot of weight, obviously, because Iowa is 0-3 against the three ranked teams he has faced and his second-best win is 4-6 Purdue. I learned that Iowa was blown away in none of its three losses, so it has to qualify. The problem is that Oklahoma State is a three-loss team with a win over the same Iowa team that Iowa lost to, and a win over No. 24 in Kansas. And speaking of Kansas State, the Wildcats have a win over No. 5 Oklahoma, while all three losses also hit the ranked teams. So wouldn't that give the two of them a more serious case at No. 20 Iowa?

Source link