Both involved young women accused of involuntary manslaughter for encouraging their boyfriends to kill themselves, according to prosecutors. Both rely on detailed evidence for a text message. Both took place in Massachusetts.
But despite their similarities, the cases have clear differences in the suicide intervention and the defendant's alleged intent.
"I think the facts will show in Carter that before that there was very limited physical contact in Carter and some very many
" said the exact opposite. We have a complete barrier. and you totally attack that person's will and conscience and psyche to set up 47,000 text messages in the last two months. "
The Case Against Inyoung You
Rollins' comments came when she announced that Inyoung You, a 21
It is alleged that you tracked the whereabouts of her boyfriend Alexander Urtula on May 20 and was present when he jumped from a parking garage a few hours before his graduation in Britain, Rollins told reporters.
Authorities said you were "physically, verbally, and psychologically abusive" to Urtula during their relationship. This abuse became more frequent, more powerful, and more humiliating in the days and hours leading to his suicide. said Rollins.
You sent him more than 47,000 text messages, and prosecutors said she had complete and total control of Urtula. She repeatedly told him to "kill herself" or "die" and that she, his family and the world would be better off without him, officials said.
In addition, she claims to have used manipulative attempts and threats of self-harm to control and isolate him from his family, officials said.
Rollins presents the case as one example of an "epidemic" of domestic violence, which she said affected people regardless of gender.
"Domestic violence may not always look the same, but it is always about power and control," she said.
You were supposed to graduate in May 2020, but I retired in August, according to a school spokesman. She is currently in her native South Korea, and the district attorney's office is "cautiously optimistic" that she will return voluntarily to the US to face the charge.
"If he doesn't, we'll use the power you have to go back," Rollins said.
In a news release, the prosecutor's office said it was working with You's lawyer to coordinate an agreement. indictment on October 18. CNN failed to contact you or her lawyer for comment.
The case against Michel Carter
As in the case of You, Carter's ordeal involved numerous intimate text messages urging her friend to go through with his suicide plan.
The defense presents Carter as a troubled, delusional young woman battling her own depression. They said Roy's death was a tragedy – but not a crime.  However, the state's highest court upheld the verdict in February, with her attorneys appealing the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court.