Home https://server7.kproxy.com/servlet/redirect.srv/sruj/smyrwpoii/p2/ US https://server7.kproxy.com/servlet/redirect.srv/sruj/smyrwpoii/p2/ The judge ruled that Bar had violated the law in electing members of the law enforcement commission

The judge ruled that Bar had violated the law in electing members of the law enforcement commission



U.S. District Judge John Bates has instructed the Presidential Law and Justice Commission not to “hold additional meetings, sessions or hearings, or conduct any official business” or “to present, receive, publish, use or rely on report or recommendations “until it meets the standards of the Federal Advisory Committee Act, as ordered.

The committee aims to examine a wide range of issues related to law enforcement and the criminal justice system in more than a dozen working groups that have had topics including “Respect for Law Enforcement”, “Victim Services” and “Youth Justice and juvenile delinquency. ” After examining the issues identified by the groups, the commission is expected to make recommendations to Barr on actions to address crime, increase respect for the law and assist victims. Bar will then pass on the recommendations for consideration to Trump.

In April, the NAACP Legal Protection Fund filed a lawsuit against Barr, the Department of Justice and the commission, alleging that they violated the Federal Advisory Committee Act by holding closed-door meetings and admitting people to urban communities who would be affected by their recommendations. .

“Especially in 2020, when problems of racial justice and civil rights, including law enforcement, have erupted across the country, the question can reasonably be asked whether it is a sensible policy group with little variety of experience to address sensitive issues behind closed doors. facing law enforcement law and the criminal justice system in America today, “Bates wrote.

Bates ruled Thursday that the commission violated federal law by failing to file a charter and not giving timely notice of any meeting in the Federal Register, “that Attorney General William P. Barr violated FACA by not selecting a designated federal official for Commission “and”
; by not ensuring that the membership of the Commission is fairly balanced in terms of the views presented and the functions to be performed, “according to the order.

A spokesman for the Ministry of Justice declined to comment.

“The Federal Advisory Committee Act was created to ensure that Federal Advisory Committees are publicly accountable for their actions. The Commission’s disregard for almost all FACA requirements is a gross violation of federal law, and we are pleased that the court has recognized this. , “Natasha Merle, a senior adviser at the NAACP Legal Protection Fund, wrote in a statement.

“Against the backdrop of a national police crisis, we need to focus more than ever on reshaping the way this country approaches public safety,” Merle said. “This requires significant engagement with the public and all stakeholders. Today’s decision ensures that the government will not be able to evade the law in order to pursue a distorted agenda.”

Bar has elected former and current law enforcement members, including U.S. attorneys, district prosecutors and police chiefs across the country. None of the members of the commission has experience in the field of criminal protection, civil rights or public organizations, the judge wrote in agreement with the Legal Protection Fund.

“The commission was set up in a way that completely ignores these provisions, aimed at ensuring that the community has access to decisions that necessarily affect them,” said Miriam Krinski, founder and CEO of the Fair and Simple Prosecution Advocacy Group. CNN. “The distorted composition of the Commission and its working groups – and its covert and closed process – underscores the bias and pre-determined agenda inherent in setting up this group.”

More than 75 current and former elected prosecutors and law enforcement officials joined the Legal Protection Fund case in a brief statement, writing that this “defective process … is the last thing a country in crisis needs.”

District Attorney John Choi resigned from the commission last month after concerns about a lack of transparency with other working groups and a lack of community members involved in their investigation were not addressed.

Source link