The 2021 NFL project is over. For the New York Giants, this was the most unusual and unexpected project in many years. Let’s look at some of the “Things I Think” about what the giants have accomplished and what they haven’t accomplished in the last three days.
GM Dave Gettleman has received widespread acclaim and many accolades from colleagues and members of the media for the Giants’ work in the now-completed project. The first two deals returned to his nine drafts as GM, a deal for the desired player that cost the giants only a choice they acquired in one of the deals, and adding three photos to the long-awaited 2022 project, which already has appraisers, drooling over the expected level of talent.
There is currently no way to know how this happens for the giants.
Maybe Kadarius Tony is a star. Maybe he̵
“I always think I understood it correctly. Listen, in three years we’ll find out if we got this right. And that’s it, fine. That’s the perception, and that’s what the media is writing about the players, “Gattleman said Saturday night. “We put a lot of time into it. We don’t do this as a hobby, well, and in three years we’ll know if we’re right or not. “
In my opinion, before we know a single thing about whether any of the players selected this year or next will succeed or fail in the NFL, the 2021 project will be the best job the giants have done in the era. of Getlman.
They were prepared in Round 1 when their original list of target players had disappeared, performing smart trade back. This is far from the failure of Eli Apple in 2016.
They read the board correctly in the 2nd round, trading back eight seats, adding a 2022 choice for the third round and still getting Ojulari, the player they thought they would choose at 42.
Going up for Aaron Robinson in Round 3 cost the giants only a fifth round, which they received from the Chicago Bears in their first deal down.
It was a project obviously different from any Gettleman that ever had a point like GM. He wasn’t like a giant either. The Giants had not made a deal back to a 2006 project, when they went back seven places and chose Matthias Kiwanuka.
All this raises the question – how much influence did the Judge have on the draft strategy of the Giants? Patriots from New England, where the referee was underestimated for several years, are known to play the board. So it’s a natural question, and a Gettleman was asked on Saturday.
“I think we have a great collaboration group here. It’s not about me. It’s not about Joe. It’s about the New York football giants, “said Getlman. “We are cooperating. We’ve been cooperating since he walked in the door. It’s about the New York Giants. “
No offensive commanders?
I have been saying for some time that perhaps the giants like the young linear ones already on their list and have higher expectations of them than many outside observers. The fact that they turned down six lineup options in the NFL project in 2021 seems to show so much.
“It’s really obvious that we have a little more confidence in our offensive commanders than you guys,” Gattleman said. “So I’m just going to say we’re happy with the band we have. Obviously you are always trying to improve and you will not take a player just to take a player, but a player because you think he will improve the value of your team. “
The Giants could stay in Round 1 and choose Northwestern’s Rashawn Slater or USC’s Alijah Vera-Tucker. They moved from number 11 to number 20 and took Tony.
In the second and third rounds, Gettleman said the Giants had identified offensive commanders of interest, but they were selected before it was the Giants’ turn to choose. They could take the Tennessee guard Trey Smith at any time on Day 3 and they didn’t. In the end, he went to 226th place with the bosses of Kansas City. The Giants seemed to feel like they couldn’t compare to value and need anywhere else when it came to offensive players, they had other players they liked, and so they came out without new pigs.
This does not mean that there will not be a new or two players on the list when the season opens in five months. There’s a part of the Gettleman quote I haven’t given you yet. Finish like this:
“At the moment, our offensive line is as it is, the players are as they are, and we will move forward.”
Catch this? Right now it is what it is. That doesn’t mean it will stay that way.
Coach Joe Judge sounded a similar refrain.
“I would say that we always strive to make each position more competitive, but at the moment we are committed to working with the guys on our list and approving each of these guys individually, and that should help the team collectively,” he said.
This, to say the least, sounds awful to me as a coach and CEO who can look at the fresh market of free agents to see who can be there, who can be released when teams re-evaluate their rosters after completion, or which can be shaken before or during a training camp.
Maybe someone like Tray Turner, whom Gattleman put together in the third round of the project in 2014, while he was CEO of the Carolina Panthers. Turner had a bad year for the Los Angeles Chargers in 2020, but will barely turn 28 next season and has been stable for six years in Carolina.
This was probably not Plan A, and with all the good things they’ve done this season, not making a significant move to improve the talent of the crime line is the area where the Giants have left themselves open to criticism.
These young attacking commanders will simply have to justify the faith that the giants have shown in them. There is a lot of riding on their success or failure.
Look for the special sauce
It had to warm Joe Judge’s heart that Gary Brightwell, Arizona, who was returning to the Giants in the sixth round on Saturday, couldn’t wait to talk about special teams when he met the media through Zoom.
“I’m excited to bring some special teams to the field. I will bring a lot of explosive plays, but my priority right now is to get the game book, join special teams and dominate, “Brightwell said when asked what he will bring to the Giants. “It’s my thing. This is my thing from high school. I was a special person in the teams. “
It also can’t get away from the giants, who pass Erson Smith, drawn in the fourth round using the 6-foot-6¼ frame, 82,-inch wingspan (85th percentile) and 41½-inch vertical jump (98th). percentile) to block two kicks in the 2019 season.
Special teams are important to the referee, a former special team coach. The Giants were not good at the coverage or the rematch a year ago. Helping to fix this had to be at least part of the reason these pictures were taken.
Impact of the list
The Giants doubled in two positions in draft, back corner and edge.
On a corner kick, this could be bad news for players like Isaac Yadom, Sam Biel and maybe even Madre Harper.
On the edge, I can’t help but wonder if Oshane Ximines from the third round for 2019 could be threatened. This coaching staff was not part of his selection. Before X-man endured his shoulder until the end of the season, he didn’t seem to have the full confidence of this staff. It will be interesting for me to see if there is a future with the Giants.
On the wide receiver, Tony, Kenny Gladay, Sterling Shepard, Darius Slayton and John Ross are listed to take five seats. That leaves guys like CJ Board, Dante Pettis, Austin Mack and David Sills V struggling to stay around.
Four of the six players that the Giants produced – Kadarius Tony, Aaron Robinson, Elerson Smith, Rodarius Williams – are the ones who left an indelible impression on the Giants in the Senior Bowl.
The Senior Bowl has always been an important part of the Giants’ puzzle project, but with time at Mobile, the only opportunity to get to know the prospects for this year’s project has become even more important.
Head coach Joe Judge admitted after the selection of Kadarius Tony that he was “very specific” about the type of people he wanted to work with. Face-to-face meetings are a key part of finding out who is right and who is wrong.
“For me, they are crucial. I really don’t like adding someone to our team or I really can’t have a strong enough opinion of someone if I haven’t interacted well enough with them as a person and there’s no better way to sit down with someone and look them in the eye eyes and really ask them difficult questions, get an answer and feel about them as a person, “said the Judge. “A number of the Senior Bowl boys we went out obviously had the ability to have a strong opinion. To be honest, the guys you only see on tape, if you don’t have enough interaction with them, you may like them as a player and there’s just something missing that you can’t stand at the table and say, this guy fits in our locker room, this person corresponds to our culture. So interactions are definitely crucial for us. “
Congratulations to Bowl Senior CEO Jim Nagy and his crew on organizing this year’s event. The Giants Board of Directors thanks you.
Brightwell is a giant because of the often despised assistant coach of special teams Tom Quinn.
The judge tells the story:
“A few weeks ago, Tom Quinn and Thomas McGough and I were sitting in the staff room on Saturday around 5:30 in the morning and Tom Quinn brought out his name and watched his kicking game and this guy was flying down the field and it was early enough to wake you up and you were really excited to see him, ‘said the Judge. “You start watching a lot more of his crime and you start talking to our scouts, who have done a lot of research on him, and talking to Burton (Burns) about returns.
“Look, he’s a man who jumps out of his skills. Always look for good flexibility and depth in these positions, running backwards and playing with kicks. To be honest with you, the opportunity I really had to talk to him and spend some time with him, even though Growing Up with Gary was over, was very, very impressive. He has a huge history. This dude gave him the biggest compliments of everyone around him on every level. He was the man who was available at the time and he was the man we could put on our roster and compete to be on the roster and make us a better team. “
So if and when Brightwell flies down the field and makes big special teams play, you can thank Quinn for the keen eye in identifying a perspective under the radar.