About an hour ago
What Pittsburgh Steelers coach Mike Tomlin decided to do with his quarterback situation was the right move.
I'm just not so sure about the logic it uses to get there.
Or why he is as sure of the decision as he seems.
On Wednesday, Tomlin was asked if Mason Rudolph would be the starting quarterback when he recovered from his concussion.
"Yes," Tomlin said emphatically. "If that makes you feel good."
Well, damn it, Mike. Anyway, I felt fine. But thank you for making such an important decision on my account.
"Seriously, boys. This person is our protector when he clears the (concussion) protocol. And it's so simple, "Tomlin replied, when I asked further what went into the decision. "We appreciate Duck's efforts. But as soon as (Rudolf) is ready to leave, he is ready to leave. "
So it seems that Hodges strictly overcame the gulf while Rudolph recovered and listened to nothing more, no matter how well
For the record, it was 22-for-29 at 200 yards with one touch and one interception for about six fourths of football.
Rudolph was 26-of-48 for 286 yards with four touchdowns and two interceptions in his first six quarters.
So the numbers seem closer than the decision-making process obviously was. Since Tomlin certainly called to face Hodge and return to Rudolph, it sounds like a no-brainer.
Honestly, I shouldn't have.
The Steelers invest a third series in Rudolph. They claim to have had the first class on it. He is a 6-foot-5, high-pedigree passer of the Power 5 conference.
Hodges is a 6-foot-1
None of this means that Hodges will ultimately not be better than Rudolph. It may already be.
But Rudolf must prove that he is worse than his public perception before Hodge shows that he is better than he is.
I'm sorry. This is exactly how it works. Franchising has more capital invested in Rudolph. The Steelers would be unwise to reject this opportunity to find out if it was worth it.
At best, their work is right for him, and over the next 11 games he shows the chops as Ben Roethlisberger's successor.
In a more conservative scenario, you can at least find out if you have a stable backup to Big Ben for his other years. Or an intriguing commercial chip.
In the worst case scenario, it bombs and you put the duck back on the lake in a few weeks.
That would be disappointing. And you'll have to admit that you blew it in the third round of the team's quarterback. But at least you gave it a legitimate shot to find out.
Instead of scrapping Rudolph for the benefit of someone you thought so little of, cut it to keep Josh Dobbs just a few weeks ago.
This has to be the thinker of Tomlin and general manager Kevin Colbert. It should be anyway. And I wholeheartedly agree with him.
What I didn't understand was the derogatory tone of Hodgis' game and his attempts to minimize Hodg's contribution to Los Angeles on Sunday.
He was not going to kill us, Tomlin said.
God. This puts a new twist on "standard" in "standard is standard", right?
“In general, he took care of the ball. He made the plays he had to do, "Tomlin explained. "But we were thinking about the position we put him in. We converted three or four falls from possession over the course. We left many others in the apartment and allowed (running back) James Connor to deliver after the catch. We did the things we needed to do to ensure victory in this case. ”
Exactly. And what did you do with Rudolf? Air? Make him hide the ball around the pitch? What games did I watch against the San Francisco 49ers, Cincinnati Bengals and Baltimore Ravens?
For crying out loud, coach. So isolating Rudolph, you're running a wild cat with a QB split. You tried to get him to spray and shovel his way to victory.
Was it really that different? It seems to me that you were quite "thinking in what positions" Rudolph was placed.
Again, I am not worried about Tomlin's decision on his concessions. I support it.
What bothers me is that Tomlin seems to be under the impression that he and offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner were somehow wide open with Rudolph's game plan, unlike Hodges.
That's all, but not true.
And that doesn't make me feel good. Even Rudolph will start next Monday night.
Tim Benz is a writer for the Tribune-Review. You can contact Tim on [email protected] or via Twitter . All Tweets can be retrieved. All emails are subject to publication unless otherwise noted.